Blog 1

     The handout of Dr. Pennock’s first chapter “An Instinct for Truth, Knowledge, Discovery” discusses the evolutionary instinct of people to be curios and how that became the driving virtue of science in order to search for empirical truths within the world. The chapter brings up important points about the purpose of science that is not discussed in classes, such as the fact that curiosity is an innate evolutionary trait. From what I understood from lectures about evolution, evolution would not give way to such traits as curiosity and in fact would favor against those traits. Yet, the chapter explains how curiosity could have evolved and allowed organisms to be more fit than others by be a driving force to search out for better resources. Even though the chapter is pretty explanatory of all the topics presented, there are a few topics discussed within the chapter that seem a little contradictory. For instance, the quote by Lewis Thomas about the characteristics about scientists is a wonderful way to build up what the chapter is about. However, the implication that Thomas was describing evolution seems to be a bit of a stretch. Thomas’s references that scientists find grabbing the answer to something is more important than feeding or breeding does not line up with the chapters later reference to Darwin’s conclusion that as humans, even though we do not have complex instincts as lower animals do, we share the instincts of self-preservation and sex drive. This calls into question than, does our instinct of curiosity somehow over ride our other and more deeply rooted instincts. The chapter does explain of how curiosity is used for self-preservation and is a competitive advantage, such as when a food resource is running low and an organism follows a scent for a possible new source. For it to be an advantage though, curiosity needs to be accompanied by caution. This made me question then where this notion of caution developed, whether it was also an evolved instinct and whether or not it is seen in other organisms and animals besides humans. Personally, I would have loved to have read more about, yet the chapter seems to drop it from there. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog 18

                Part two of the biography Albert Einstein: Ideas and Opinions described Einstein’s views of politics, government, and pacifism. All of the excerpts about Einstein’s views of these areas are very insightful and important to consider, the one that stood out to me the most and seemed as the best summation of his other accounts of pacifism was the section “The pacifist problem.” In it Einstein talks about people should not rely solely on the government to solve all sorts of problems and deny that the problem involves them in anyway. He goes on to state that it is a person’s job and right to stand up for their morals conscientious objection alongside other organizations with the same ideals, even if that means standing against one’s government. Darwin and McClintock demonstrated this kind of conscientious objection when both stood up for their research and fought for the truths of their discoveries to be made known despite the backlash they had to face from it. In this day
Read more

Blog 2

        The first eight chapters of Franklin’s Autobiography describe his early life through his travels and beginnings in Philadelphia. As I read through the autobiography, there were a few things about both Franklin’s characteristics and some of the situations that he went through that stood out to me. Franklin for the most part did not seem to complain about anything he’s was going through. He might have in person and there were a few disgruntled writings such as mentioning that he and the others that were heading for Amboy had been on the water for thirty hours with no food or drink; yet, his writing style and how he would switch to a happier topic showed that it really did not bother him. Often in today’s society, we find it so easy to complain about things since everything is nearly handed to us. When it is this easy for us to be warm and sheltered, well fed, and go nearly anywhere without having to walk the whole distance, we tend to get upset at whatever does not follow this
Read more

Blog 4

                The second chapter of Dr. Pennock’s book builds upon the notion of virtue theory by presenting the idea of internal and external goods, how those goods relate to science, and the way science has been and can be shaped by which goods a scientist chooses to focus on. Personally, I found the discussion of MacIntyre’s quotes about internal and external goods interesting. It made me think of some kind of operant conditioning that either someone can put someone through or that one can put oneself through. This kind of conditioning or choice between reaching for the internal good of something (the feeling of joy of performing or completing a task) or for the external good (gaining a reward for completing a task) is a choice that we have to face every day, and not just in professional settings. Although, as Dr. Pennock shows later in the chapter, the effect of this choice does play an important role in the efficacy of a professional practice, especially science. Dr. Pennock pro
Read more