Blog 12

                Chapters nine through twelve of A Feeling for the Organism describe the difficulties McClintock had in sharing her newly discovered transposition genes to her colleagues and how the advancement of molecular biology supported McClintock’s findings years later. It was only until discoveries made by molecular biologists such as Peter Starlinger and Heinz Saedler, and Monod and Jacob that people began to understand and accept McClintock’s previous findings, though it was still an uphill battle for her the whole time. What I think though was the two main initial barriers that kept people from believing in McClintock’s findings were her poor communication of the findings and her lack of social relations with her colleagues. Though communicating new results to others who have no expertise in the field is difficult, the way McClintock went about it did not help either. Learning how to be able to simplify what one is trying to teach takes a long time and though she would have had a fair amount of practice of doing this, I cannot fault her for possibly not doing this in the best way. However, her lack of trying to meet a middle ground and expecting only success is what her main fault was. Since she did not know how to react to people not agreeing with her because she expected that she was always right, her explanations of transposition genes only became more complex and difficult for others to understand. Also, her lack of relations with these colleagues caused them to be fairly skeptical of her. Both sides did not share much respect for each and therefore led to ill support for McClintock’s findings and for her to not try to work on their level of understanding. The ability to properly share one’s work with others, the mutual help and support between colleagues, and to not hold oneself higher above everyone else are all necessary virtues within the field of science. One can read this chapter in McClintock’s biography and see how the lack of these virtues will only cause one grief. Therefore, one should learn from McClintock’s experience that in order to truly succeed in the field of science, one must practice these virtues as well and not just be a methodical intellectual.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog 18

                Part two of the biography Albert Einstein: Ideas and Opinions described Einstein’s views of politics, government, and pacifism. All of the excerpts about Einstein’s views of these areas are very insightful and important to consider, the one that stood out to me the most and seemed as the best summation of his other accounts of pacifism was the section “The pacifist problem.” In it Einstein talks about people should not rely solely on the government to solve all sorts of problems and deny that the problem involves them in anyway. He goes on to state that it is a person’s job and right to stand up for their morals conscientious objection alongside other organizations with the same ideals, even if that means standing against one’s government. Darwin and McClintock demonstrated this kind of conscientious objection when both stood up for their research and fought for the truths of their discoveries to be made known despite the backlash they had to face from it. In this day
Read more

Blog 2

        The first eight chapters of Franklin’s Autobiography describe his early life through his travels and beginnings in Philadelphia. As I read through the autobiography, there were a few things about both Franklin’s characteristics and some of the situations that he went through that stood out to me. Franklin for the most part did not seem to complain about anything he’s was going through. He might have in person and there were a few disgruntled writings such as mentioning that he and the others that were heading for Amboy had been on the water for thirty hours with no food or drink; yet, his writing style and how he would switch to a happier topic showed that it really did not bother him. Often in today’s society, we find it so easy to complain about things since everything is nearly handed to us. When it is this easy for us to be warm and sheltered, well fed, and go nearly anywhere without having to walk the whole distance, we tend to get upset at whatever does not follow this
Read more

Blog 4

                The second chapter of Dr. Pennock’s book builds upon the notion of virtue theory by presenting the idea of internal and external goods, how those goods relate to science, and the way science has been and can be shaped by which goods a scientist chooses to focus on. Personally, I found the discussion of MacIntyre’s quotes about internal and external goods interesting. It made me think of some kind of operant conditioning that either someone can put someone through or that one can put oneself through. This kind of conditioning or choice between reaching for the internal good of something (the feeling of joy of performing or completing a task) or for the external good (gaining a reward for completing a task) is a choice that we have to face every day, and not just in professional settings. Although, as Dr. Pennock shows later in the chapter, the effect of this choice does play an important role in the efficacy of a professional practice, especially science. Dr. Pennock pro
Read more